Comprehensive Financial Advisory Committee | Feb. 10, 2025

The meeting focused on discussion regarding a proposal from the Barnstable Public Schools Facility Subcommittee to consolidate two elementary schools (Hyannis West and Barnstable Community Intermediate School) and build a new K-3 school.

Watch the meeting. AI generated summary below. Corrections welcome; see contact page.

---

Key Points

• Financial Justification: The subcommittee argues that building a new school is more cost-effective in the long run than renovating existing facilities, citing high repair costs and the potential for economies of scale in a consolidated building. They presented estimates of $22 million for repairs versus $43.5 million (after a 50% state subsidy) for new construction.
• Educational Needs: The subcommittee emphasizes that current facilities are inadequate for modern teaching methods and lack the space to comply with regulations. They also highlight the need to remain competitive with neighboring towns that have newer school facilities.
• Community Outreach: The subcommittee acknowledges that they are in the early stages of the process and have not yet formally presented a proposal to the Town Council. They plan extensive community outreach before any proposal goes to a town-wide vote.
• Debt Exclusion: The proposal would require a debt exclusion, which has a low historical success rate in Barnstable. The possibility of extending the debt financing term from 30 to 40 years under a new state bill was discussed.
• Timing and Competition: Concerns were raised about the timing of a potential debt exclusion for the school project, particularly in relation to other upcoming projects like the Clean Water Management Plan (CWMP). The long lead time for new school construction (7-10 years) was also highlighted.
• Alternative Solutions: The possibility of increasing the percentage of the town budget allocated to school maintenance and repairs was suggested as a temporary measure to address immediate needs.
• Metrics for Success: The subcommittee emphasized that a key metric for success would be the more efficient use of taxpayer dollars. Other metrics discussed included increased student enrollment, improved educational outcomes, and the creation of a community center within the new school building.